Magic Puzzle Company — The Secret Soup
The Magic Puzzle Company delivers a truly secret experience. Read this spoiler-free review before you open the box.
*Originally published on MyPuzzleDay.com — May 10, 2023*
⚠️ Affiliate Disclosure: This post contains Amazon affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, I earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
The Magic Puzzle Company is famous for adding a truly unique, hidden twist to every box, and their latest release, “The Secret Soup,” is no exception. This puzzle is designed to be an experience, challenging you not just with the pieces, but with a secret that is only revealed at the very end.
This review covers the stunning custom art, the excellent piece quality, and the overall puzzling difficulty—everything you need to know before you start assembling. We promise this entire section is 100% spoiler-free and will keep the final magic completely safe!
Just The Deets!
✦ Piece Cut: Unique
✦ Piece Fit: Loose
✦ False Fits: Possible
✦ Piece Gauge: 1.98mm
✦ Puzzle Finish: Low Gloss
✦ Reference Poster: Yes
✦ Dust Level: Low
✦ Box Quality: Sturdy Cardboard
✦ Puzzle Size 1000 Piece: 28” x 21”
✦ Made in China
Image Quality & Themes
The images on the puzzles are original artworks and each is listed on the back of the box. The Secret Soup artwork is done by Margaux Peltat. I cannot say enough about how many details there are in this puzzle. It is BEYOND amazing. Beautiful and varied illustrations over every inch. Gorgeous!!
All the artwork for the puzzles is original. There is a great variety in style and color and I chose The Secret Soup as the colors and illustrations were the first to catch my eye.
🧩 Hands-On Experience: Quality, Packaging, and the Hunt
This section covers the hands-on quality of The Secret Soup puzzle, focusing on packaging, included materials, and the challenging “Easter Eggs” hunt.
The packaging is very high quality and unexpected at the price point. The included materials enhance the solving experience significantly: they provide 2 poster inserts so the puzzle can be worked by more than one person at a time without having to share.
One unexpected and enjoyable challenge is the included “Easter Eggs” list, which is a heck of a challenge on its own! I thoroughly enjoyed the hunt and used both the puzzle image and the included poster to find everything, along with a magnifying glass.
The Magic Puzzle Company website has a nice section at the bottom of the page that addresses anticipated questions—two of which I had, and both of which were answered. I definitely recommend checking out their website if you have questions!
Finally, note that this is not a puzzle I would preserve to frame, as by its nature, it’s meant to be shared. Magic Puzzle Company even provides a repackaging guide.
Pros and Cons
✅ Pros (The Experience & Quality)
◆ Excellent Value: Very high quality and unexpected packaging at the price point.
◆ Collaborative: Includes 2 poster inserts for simultaneous solving.
◆ Extra Challenge: The included “Easter Eggs” list is a fun, separate challenge.
◆ Great Support: The website provides a helpful FAQ section for anticipated questions.
❌ Cons (Minor Imperfections)
◆ Loose Piece Fit: The piece fit was loose enough to be slightly frustrating.
◆ Tool Required: Moving smaller sections (even 4 pieces) without the aid of a tool meant the section needed to be rebuilt.
◆ Not Framable: This puzzle is designed to be shared and broken down, not preserved.
💖 Final Thoughts: Is The Secret Soup Worth It?
If you are looking for a puzzle experience that is truly different, the answer is an overwhelming yes.
The Magic Puzzle Company delivers on its promise of high quality and unique engagement right out of the box. From the unexpected packaging and the fun Easter Egg hunt to the two included posters, this puzzle offers an experience that goes beyond the typical tray-and-lid setup.
The loose piece fit requires you to keep a setting tool handy and definitely impacts assembly speed, but this small drawback is easily outweighed by the innovation and joy packed into the box.
For any puzzler seeking a memorable challenge designed to be shared—and not just another picture to frame—the Magic Puzzle Company puzzles, and specifically “The Secret Soup,” are highly recommended.
Grab your own copy of ‘The Secret Soup’ on Amazon and experience the magic before someone spoils the secret!