Toy Wonderama: Volume 2 — The Evolution of Aimee Stewart’s Playful Nostalgia
Comparing two masterworks: How Buffalo Games’ reimagining of a fan-favorite theme takes us deeper into the vintage toy box.
⚠️ Affiliate Disclosure: This post contains Amazon affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, I earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
If you’re a regular here, you likely remember my deep dive into the Big Ben version of Toy Wonderama. While many artists simply license one image to multiple brands, Aimee Stewart often creates “sister pieces”—entirely new compositions that inhabit the same world. Think of this Buffalo Games release (c. 2021) as “Volume 2” to the original Big Ben edition (c. 2014). It isn’t a reprint; it’s a reimagining that shows just how much her digital artistry evolved over that seven-year gap.
While both puzzles share the same name and Stewart’s signature “organized chaos,” the Buffalo version trades the original’s carnival rides and monster kits for an expanded “Town and Country” feel. Today, we’re stepping back up to the toy chest to see how the collection has grown and why this newer volume deserves its own spot on your assembly board.
✨ Side-by-Side: What’s in the Box?
At first glance, both puzzles feel like looking into the same magical attic, but once you start sorting pieces, you’ll realize these are two entirely different inventories. The Big Ben (2014) version leans heavily into the Spectacle of the Fairground. Its shelves are dominated by large-scale mechanical wonders: towering Ferris wheels, elaborate carousels, and the “Monster Lab” kits that defined the mid-century hobby craze. It feels like a vertical slice of a bustling 1950s boardwalk.
In contrast, the Buffalo Games (2021) version shifts the focus toward Town and Country play. The bottom shelf alone is a massive departure, featuring a sprawling “Chisholm Trail” western set and miniature storefronts like a “Post Office” and “Barber Shop.” While the Big Ben version feels “tall” and dense, the Buffalo version feels “wide” and narrative, trading the vertical carnival rides for a majestic “Ring Circus” train and an expanded array of animals—from zebras to elephants—that give it a more whimsical, storybook atmosphere.
Beyond the change in toys, the color palette itself has undergone a dramatic transformation: while the Big Ben version uses softer, muted tones that evoke a true 'aged vintage' feel, the Buffalo Games release bursts with vivid, high-saturation colors that make the tin toys feel brand new and freshly polished.
Even the “Space Patrol” toys—a signature of both—have been completely swapped. In the Big Ben version, we see the “Space Ship X-2” and a silver bipedal robot. By 2021, Aimee had “upgraded” the Buffalo version with a massive “Space Port” center-piece and the iconic “Television Robot.” It’s a fascinating look at how her personal collection of vintage references (and her digital painting style) became more intricate and color-saturated over that seven-year gap.
🎯 The Buffalo Games Experience: A Modern Standard
If you’re moving from the Big Ben version to the Buffalo Games edition, the most immediate difference isn’t just what’s on the shelves—it’s how the pieces feel in your hands. Buffalo Games has become a go-to for Aimee Stewart fans for a reason: their “Perfect Snap™” technology. Unlike the often looser fit of older Big Ben puzzles, these pieces are designed to fit together with a satisfying, audible click, making it much easier to move finished sections around your board without them crumbling.
One of the greatest “quality of life” upgrades in this version is the inclusion of a full-color bonus poster. Because Stewart’s “Toy Wonderama” is so dense with tiny text and minute details—like the “5¢” price on a candy jar or the intricate gears on a tin robot—trying to work off the small box lid can be a strain. The poster allows you to see every brushstroke of the 2021 digital update, which features sharper lines and more vibrant color saturation than its 2014 predecessor.
Finally, there’s the environmental and practical side. Buffalo puzzles are made from 100% recycled puzzle board, and the box itself is more compact and shelf-friendly than the larger Big Ben rectangles. For a post-2020 puzzle release, it hits all the modern marks: sturdy, high-definition, and built for a seamless assembly experience that lets you focus entirely on the “I Spy” joy of the artwork.
🔥Why Aimee Stewart Matters to Puzzlers
What makes both versions of Toy Wonderama so addictive is what fans often call the “I Spy” factor. Aimee Stewart doesn’t just paint a picture; she builds a world where every single piece of the puzzle—whether it’s a tiny tin wheel or the snout of a plastic zebra—is a mini-project in itself. This is “Zen puzzling” at its finest. You don’t need the box lid to know where a piece of the “Space Port” or the “Chisholm Trail” wagon goes; the details are that distinct.
Beyond the mechanics of the build, there is a deep “Nostalgia Trap” at play here. Stewart has a gift for capturing the feeling of being a child staring at a store shelf just out of reach. Over the seven years between these two releases, you can see her leaning further into this. The 2021 Buffalo version feels more curated, with cleaner lines and a richer “glow” that highlights the textures of the tin and wood. It’s a testament to her evolution as a digital artist—she hasn’t just added more toys; she’s mastered the ability to make them feel tangible.
💡 Final Thoughts: A Collection Worth Completing
So, do you need both? For most Aimee Stewart fans, the answer is a resounding yes. While they share a name, they offer two completely different “play sessions.” The Big Ben version is a trip to the carnival, while the Buffalo Games version is a journey through a classic town square.
If you enjoyed the challenge of the original, the 2021 reimagining is a beautiful way to see how an artist can revisit a favorite theme and find entirely new stories to tell. It’s not just a puzzle; it’s a second volume in a nostalgia-soaked library that I’m more than happy to keep on my shelf.
❓Looking at these two shelves, which toy would you have reached for first as a kid? Are you team 'Big Ben Ferris Wheel' or team 'Buffalo Games Circus Train'?